Bagel Bros Cafe

1216 S Bay St, Eustis, FL 32726, United States
+1 352-308-8531
$$$ Cafe
(34 Reviews)
Price Range $1–10

Welcome to Bagel Bros Cafe, your new favorite destination for a delightful breakfast or snack located at 1216 S Bay St, Eustis, FL 32726. This charming café captures the essence of a New York bagel shop right in the heart of Florida, offering freshly baked bagels and a cozy atmosphere that invites you to take a moment for yourself.

As you step inside, the enticing aroma of freshly baked bagels wafts through the air, wrapping you in a warm embrace. The cafe is adorned with friendly decor and a welcoming vibe, making it the perfect spot to unwind or catch up with friends over a delicious meal.

The menu is a bagel lover’s dream, with a wonderful selection that highlights traditional favorites and unique creations. Start your day off right with their Egg Plates; the Eggs with Sausage, Bacon, Ham, or Taylor Ham served alongside crispy potatoes is a hearty choice at just US$9.49. If you're feeling a bit more adventurous, try the popular Bagel Benedict, a twist on eggs benedict served on one of their freshly baked bagels.

For something lighter, the café also offers a variety of Artisan Sandwiches like the Tuna Sandwich teamed with a pickle at US$9.75 or the lovingly crafted Egg Salad on toasted white bread. Each sandwich promises to deliver a satisfying crunch and flavor explosion with every bite. You'll also find the classic Grilled Cheese Sandwich for just US$4.69, bringing comfort food to a whole new level.

Of course, no café experience is complete without refreshments. Grab a refreshing Blue Gatorade for just US$2.49 or indulge in a Pure Leaf Unsweet Tea for US$3.49 – perfect companions to your meal.

Don't just take our word for it; customers rave about their experiences! Christian Rodriguez shared his excitement about finding real bagels and Taylor ham, stating he couldn’t resist ordering two sandwiches on his first visit. Jean Szablowski remarked on the amazing customer service and the hard-to-find sea salt bagels that were a hit with her and her daughter. Meanwhile, Ayanna McIntosh emphasized the friendly staff and fantastic variety of cream cheese flavors, especially the honey cinnamon.

While some visitors have noted that parking can be a challenge, most agree that the experience is well worth it. Bagel Bros Cafe is not merely a place to grab a bite; it's a community hub where locals gather for delicious food and a friendly chat. So, whether you're a bagel enthusiast or just searching for a cozy spot to enjoy breakfast, Bagel Bros Cafe should be high on your list of places to visit!

Offerings
Coffee
Dining options
Catering
Parking
Free parking lot
Openings Hours

Monday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Tuesday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Wednesday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Thursday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Friday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Saturday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Sunday

06:30 AM - 02:00 PM

34 Reviews
Christian Rodriguez

15 Sep 2025

1st time, I stopped looking for real bagels! Found out they have Taylor ham!! If you know… you know…So I got a 2 sandwiches!

G H

15 Aug 2025

The bagels are pretty good. I won’t be doing the steak, egg and cheese bagel again because I’m not a big fan of the steak meat they use. Bacon, sausage, ham… you can’t go wrong there. They were quick and friendly and the store was quaint and clean.

Billie Drummond

26 Jul 2025

The bagels and cream cheese are excellent. Staff is always very nice. The last couple times we have been there, our order always has an additional charge on it. This past time I asked why the additional charge for a veggie bagel (regular bagel) no cheese or veggies on top. I was told certain bagels like the chocolate chip and the colorful bagel is extra. Why is veggie extra when the ones with cheese and toppings ones are not. The menu board states all bagels the one price with cream cheese or without. Not that .50 cents is a lot but over a lot of different customers a day it adds up. Just feel they should honor the prices on the menu. Parking is also not easy access.

Jean Szablowski

16 Jul 2025

My daughter and I stopped in this morning to finally try their bagels, and we were not disappointed. First their customer service is amazing. They have a great selection of bagels to choose from. I was happy to find sea salt bagels they are my favorite and not offered at many places. We both kept it simple and got bagels with cream cheese and loved them. I highly recommend trying them out if you have not.

Dana Ellerby

28 Jun 2025

I used to drive all the way to Lake Mary for a bagel and now finally we have a great bagel place. Only downside is parking .

Shreyas Shah

21 Jun 2025

Great local bagel store. NY style bagels with quick and friendly service. No nonsense bagels with lots of variety, that said the standards were as expected and will certainly be back. Surprising the dearth of quality bagel places in the area but this place makes up for it. Not sure about all the comments about parking, had no issues and while not a real sit down restaurant, they do have some tables inside and outside for a quick bite and coffee.

Ayanna Mcintosh

13 Jun 2025

I just would love to say this is an amazing bagel place !! The staff are amazing kind friendly and personable!!!! This is my second time here and both times were phenomenal!!! They have great bagels all different kinds amazing cream cheese my fave is the honey cinnamon. they have amazing sweets and bake goods !!! . And its truly a blessing to just chill at and eat breakfast have friendly staff and have an amazing breakfast!!!! BTW their coffees are amazing!!! .I want to also give a big thanks to Anthony one of the managers he so kind !!and made my day !!!with great energy and kindness!!!again I totally recommend this place!!!.if you happen to be in eustis its place you gotta try !!God bless

Join the Bagel Bros Cafe Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.